AI·News & analysis
Etsy sellers are leaving over new terms that allow AI training
Etsy's updated Terms of Use, effective December 16, let the company and its partners train AI on seller content, and many longtime sellers are closing their shops in protest.

Tide
Wave
Sci-fi
3/10
Reality
Shipping
A shop terms page decides who gets to teach the machines.How we rate
Etsy's updated Terms of Use, effective December 16, 2026, explicitly let Etsy and its third-party partners use seller content to train AI.
Sellers keep ownership, but the license they grant is perpetual and irrevocable. Many longtime sellers are closing shops. Etsy says it does not train AI to copy sellers' work, yet no general opt-out has been announced for US sellers, and the rules take effect in the middle of the holiday selling season.
What to know
- Etsy's updated Terms of Use, published October 26 and effective December 16, 2026, explicitly let Etsy and its third-party partners use seller content to train AI.
- Sellers keep ownership of their work, but the license they grant Etsy is perpetual and irrevocable, so deleting a listing may not end it.
- On November 16, Etsy's VP of Customer Operations said the company does not train AI designed to copy sellers' work or replace their creativity.
- No general opt-out has been announced for US sellers who want to keep selling while excluding their content.
Etsy has told its sellers that it, and the partners it chooses, may use their shop content to train AI. Plenty of sellers have answered by closing their shops.
The fight is about a few lines in a terms page. Here is what changed, what Etsy says it means, and what stays unclear.
What changed in Etsy's terms?
Etsy published updated Terms of Use and Privacy Policy on October 26, 2026. They take effect on December 16.
The old terms already gave Etsy a broad license to use what sellers upload. A license here is simply permission to use the work. The new text adds one explicit sentence about AI.
It says the license includes "the right for us and our third party partners and vendors to use Your Content to develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies." The goal, the terms say, includes improving the services or helping keep them safe. The right is "subject to any applicable opt-out rights" in the Privacy Policy.
The Privacy Policy now names listing information, product reviews and community posts as examples of content that may be used to train AI. It lists this under Etsy's legitimate business interests, which is the legal reason a company gives for handling data.
Sellers still own their work, but the permission they give Etsy to use it now spells out AI training.
What does the license actually allow?
Sellers keep ownership of their listing photos, descriptions, videos, reviews and community posts. That has not changed.
What they grant Etsy is a license with several strong words in it. It is non-exclusive, worldwide, royalty-free, irrevocable, sublicensable and perpetual.
Here is what each word means in plain terms:
- Non-exclusive: the seller can still use the work anywhere else.
- Royalty-free: Etsy does not pay for using it.
- Irrevocable and perpetual: the seller cannot take it back, and it does not expire.
- Sublicensable: Etsy can pass the permission on to others.
Because the license is perpetual and irrevocable, deleting a listing or closing a shop may not end Etsy's permission over what was already uploaded. Etsy has not said how it treats that older material in AI training data or models.
What does Etsy say about it?
On November 16, James Ossman, Etsy's VP of Customer Operations, answered the backlash in a post on the Etsy Community site.
He wrote that sellers keep ownership of their creative work. He also wrote: "We do not use your content to train AI models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity." He added that this is not changing.
Ossman listed what Etsy does train AI for:
- Fraud: models that spot suspicious accounts and related listings.
- Search: AI that understands the marketplace inventory so buyers find items and get tailored recommendations.
- Seller tools: features that help sellers run their businesses and understand their buyers.
An Etsy spokesperson gave a similar explanation. The update lets Etsy use user content to improve large language models, which are the AI systems behind chatbots. Etsy says these power things like shop tools, relevant search results and fraud detection.
Etsy also says the update does not change how it has operated.
Why are sellers leaving anyway?
Many sellers say words matter more than intentions. A perpetual license that mentions "partners and vendors" is broad, and the post did not close every gap.
Etsy did not say whether authorized partners can use seller content to train models for products unrelated to Etsy. It also did not announce a general opt-out for US sellers who want to keep selling without their content being used.
The terms refer to opt-out rights in the Privacy Policy. Sellers in the European Union and the UK may have extra rights to object to the processing of personal information. Those rights do not necessarily cover every kind of creative content on the marketplace.
The mood showed up on social media. Many artists and crafters posted goodbye notes and flyers drawn in their own styles as they closed their shops.
Others said they feel stuck. Etsy is their main income, and the change landed at the busiest selling time of the year. Some are writing to customers and asking them to shop with them directly instead.
In real life a seller of hand-painted mugs photographs her best work for her listings. Under the new terms, Etsy and its partners may use that photo to teach AI, even if she later takes the mug off sale.
Is this really new?
Not entirely. The earlier terms already included the broad license, but they described it mainly in terms of running and promoting the marketplace. Examples included translating listing descriptions, improving photos or featuring a seller's items in ads.
Etsy has also been experimenting with AI for a while. In August 2025, it described tests that used internal employee documents and past seller community discussions to build Etsy-specific question-and-answer tools. That method adds the material to the question rather than retraining the AI on it.
Etsy has also limited public access to parts of its seller forums. That makes the information harder for outside AI companies to collect, while Etsy keeps access for its own technology.
What about outside AI companies and shopping bots?
The same update draws a firmer line around Etsy's data. The terms now expressly bar third parties from using content or data from Etsy to develop, train, fine-tune, evaluate or benchmark AI systems without Etsy's permission. That applies whether the data was collected by hand or by automated tools.
Etsy also added tighter rules for automated shopping agents. These include bots, scripts, browser extensions and AI tools that act for users. Etsy reserves the right to allow, restrict or ban them. Approved agents may need to say who they represent, and users are responsible for what their agents do.
This matters because more shopping is starting in AI assistants. Etsy has been an early partner in ChatGPT's Instant Checkout, which OpenAI later paused, and keeps working with other AI shopping services. The new rules give Etsy a say over who gets to list and buy its products through those tools.
What came right before?
Four days before the terms were published, Etsy announced stricter rules for AI-generated listings. It banned AI-made craft patterns and other functional instructions. It banned fully automated AI listings. It also required unedited photos of real products in more cases.
Etsy said buyer confusion about AI-generated content had become one of the top three barriers to shopping more often on the site. AI artwork with the seller's own creative input and disclosure is still allowed.
Many sellers welcomed that crackdown. The terms update, arriving so soon after, then hit the same community.
What it means for you
- If you sell on Etsy: read the new terms before December 16. Check the Privacy Policy for the opt-out rights it mentions, and note that US sellers have no general opt-out so far.
- If you are an EU or UK seller: you may have extra rights to object to how personal information is processed.
- If you buy on Etsy: you may see fewer shops from artists who left, especially small ones.
- If you are on the fence: closing a shop may not end the license on what you already uploaded, so weigh that before you decide.
The bottom line
Etsy says it will not train AI to copy sellers' work. It has also written into its terms that it and its partners can train AI on that work, and that is what pushed many sellers out the door.
The gaps are the opt-out and the older uploads. Until Etsy answers those, some sellers will keep leaving, and others will watch the December 16 date with a lot of unease.
Key facts
- Terms published
- October 26, 2026
- Takes effect
- December 16, 2026
- Etsy's clarification
- November 16 Community post
- General US opt-out
- None announced
Got questions?
Quick answers, plain wordsWhat changed in Etsy's terms?
The updated Terms of Use add an explicit right for Etsy and its third-party partners and vendors to use seller content to develop, train, test and improve AI and machine-learning technologies. They were published on October 26 and take effect on December 16, 2026.
Do sellers still own their work?
Yes. Sellers keep ownership of listing photos, descriptions, videos, reviews and community posts. They grant Etsy a non-exclusive, worldwide, royalty-free, irrevocable, sublicensable and perpetual license to use that content.
Does Etsy train AI to copy sellers' designs?
Etsy says it does not. In a November 16 Community post, VP of Customer Operations James Ossman wrote that Etsy does not use seller content to train AI models designed to copy original work or replace creativity, and that this is not changing.
What does Etsy say it uses AI for?
Etsy lists three uses: spotting fraudulent accounts and listings, understanding marketplace inventory so buyers find items through search and recommendations, and building AI-powered seller tools that help run a shop.
Can sellers opt out?
The terms mention applicable opt-out rights in the Privacy Policy, but no general mechanism has been identified for US sellers to exclude their listing photos or descriptions from AI training while still selling. Sellers in the EU and UK may have extra rights to object to the processing of personal information.
Does deleting a listing or closing a shop stop the license?
Not necessarily. Because the license is perpetual and irrevocable, removing a listing or closing a shop may not end Etsy's permission to use content already uploaded. Etsy has not explained how it treats that material in AI training data or models.
Is Etsy training AI on seller content for the first time?
Not necessarily. The older license was already broad, and Etsy says the update is not a change in existing practice. The new language simply spells out AI training in the terms.
Which rules cover outside companies and AI shopping agents?
The updated terms bar third parties from using Etsy content or data to develop, train or test AI systems without permission. Etsy also reserves the right to allow, limit or ban automated shopping agents, and those agents may have to identify who they act for.
Where are sellers going?
Some are moving to smaller marketplaces that position themselves as anti-AI, such as Marmalade Handmade and the UK-based Folksy. Others say they cannot leave because Etsy is their main income, and are asking customers to buy from them directly.
SourcesEtsy
Topics and tagsetsy, ai training, creators, privacy
Go deeper
- ExplainerWhat is a large language model (LLM)?A large language model is an AI system trained on huge amounts of text to predict the next word. That simple skill,...
- ExplainerWhat is fine-tuning an AI model?Fine-tuning takes an AI model that has already learned from huge amounts of general data and trains it a bit more on...
Related stories

Meta lets smart glasses owners opt out of AI training on their visual data
A new setting in the Meta AI app lets smart glasses owners stop Meta from using camera-fed 'visual data' to train its AI models, though opting out can disable some features.

Meta pauses Muse chat sharing after 6,800 links surface in DNS
Security firm Claroc found that Muse's share links could be listed through public DNS records. Meta has paused sharing while it reviews the design.

ChatGPT now lets you lock sensitive chats behind a PIN
OpenAI is rolling out Locked Chats in ChatGPT. Protect a conversation with a four-digit PIN or Face ID, but know it is not end-to-end encryption.
More in brief
- ASELSAN's EJDERHA electromagnetic weapon disables 51 drones with one commandNov 21
- Microsoft To Do will shut down on June 30, 2027Nov 21
- Medtronic's Hugo surgical robot cleared for general surgery in the USNov 21
- Google's Gemini now turns noisy fire radio into text for Watch DutyNov 21
- Internet Archive staff move to unionize with CWANov 20
- Meta rethinks its 2030 net-zero goal as AI pushes emissions up 45%Nov 20